The short version for anyone who already owns Pikmin 4: the Switch 2 upgrade is cheap, it's prettier, and it still runs at 30fps. That's the shape of Nintendo Life's video review of Pikmin 4 Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy, which adapts Jim Norman's written review and lands on a 7/10.
Xarmo covered the Pikmin Day announcement and demo earlier this month. This is about whether the finished upgrade is worth your money, going by Nintendo Life's review; it isn't a hands-on verdict.
What your US$9.99 buys
If you own the Switch 1 game, the upgrade path costs £7.99 or US$9.99. For that, the review lists:
- Native 4K when docked. It's a resolution bump, and the review's honest take is that it isn't transformative, because Pikmin 4 already looked great on Switch 1.
- Howl-Outs. You can shout commands at Oatchi through the Switch 2 microphone. Cute, the review says, but inconsistent and inessential.
- GameShare for Dandori Battles. The written review notes you can share the head-to-head mode across consoles.
- Dandori Academy. The headline addition is a mode of timed treasure-clearing challenges: 72 stages rolling out at six a month over a year, with practice during the week and an "exam" at the weekend for medals and rewards.
That last one is the sleeper. Dandori stages were a highlight of the original game, and a year of new ones is real replay value for the price of a couple of coffees.
What it doesn't fix
Here's the catch, and the review doesn't hide it. There's no 60fps mode and no mouse controls, and the review calls both omissions puzzling. Dandori Academy's drip-feed also means the new content feels slight on day one. The written review sums it up as "more of a budding shoot right now than the full-bloom upgrade" the reviewer was hoping for.
The video then hands over to its presenter for some extra thoughts: Pikmin 4 is probably the best game in the series, the 30fps cap is still a letdown, and the new content offers little reason to return if you've already finished the game on Switch 1.
What the comments say
The 30fps call set off the biggest argument under the video. One camp couldn't believe a Switch 2 Edition stays at 30fps; another argued the game's timings are built around that frame rate, so doubling it would mean far more work than a patch. Elsewhere, plenty of people said the upgrade price is low enough to try anyway, especially if they never finished the game or just want to yell at Oatchi. A few weren't keen on Dandori Academy tying events to real days of the week, which doesn't suit anyone who only plays when they can.
Verdict
If you own Pikmin 4 and never finished the Dandori challenges, or you're happy to dip in for six new stages a month, US$9.99 is an easy yes. You get a sharper picture, a year of new challenges and a microphone gimmick, which is a fair trade at that price.
If you were waiting for a smoother, mouse-controlled Pikmin 4, this isn't it. Save your money and keep an eye on Pikmin 5.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes



