Metaphor: ReFantazio on Switch 2 is a great RPG in a shaky port, Nintendo Life finds

Nintendo Life calls Metaphor: ReFantazio an extraordinary JRPG and scores the Switch 2 version 8/10, but says inconsistent frame rates and muddy visuals hold the port back in every mode.

Mia Hart

An open book on a pedestal releasing golden ribbons of light into the sky

Metaphor: ReFantazio arrives on Switch 2 on 12 November, and Nintendo Life's video review puts the question most buyers actually have in its title: is it worth it? The short answer from Nintendo Life is yes, with a caveat that matters more than usual. The game is excellent. This version of it isn't as polished as it should be.

The video, presented by Nintendo Life's Mai Ladyman, adapts Joe Hill's written review, which scores it 8/10, and then adds Ladyman's own impressions. Xarmo hasn't played this version; what follows assesses the published review and the reaction to it.

What Nintendo Life likes

The praise is for the game itself, and it's strong. The review singles out the story, the characters and the themes, calls the combat arguably the best Atlus has delivered in an RPG, and rates the art direction and Shoji Meguro's soundtrack highly. Its summary is that Metaphor is "an extraordinary JRPG, juggling stories and systems alike with grace and effortlessness".

None of that is a surprise if you followed the game's original release. What the review suggests is that the move to Switch 2 hasn't cost the game those strengths; the problems it lists are all technical.

Where the port falls short

The problems are technical, and they're consistent. The Switch 2 version offers performance, balanced and graphics modes, in handheld and docked play. According to the written review, the frame rate wobbles whichever one you choose, and the image has muddy textures and odd anti-aliasing. The reviewer's phrase for it is "beautiful and hideous at the same time", and the line that sums up the deduction is blunt: "there's no metaphor for a dodgy frame rate and visuals."

There's one smaller gripe that isn't about the port: side dungeons can be dull and repetitive.

Ladyman's own section of the video adds a useful practical note: performance mode looked poor to Ladyman in both handheld and docked play, and graphics mode was the preferred way to play.

The practical trade-off is this. Three modes usually means you can pick the compromise you prefer, smoother or sharper. Nintendo Life's finding is that none of them removes the inconsistency, so the mode menu is less of a fix than it looks.

What the comments say

The mood under the video splits neatly into two groups. One is excited: people who waited for a Nintendo version, people with steelbook pre-orders, and plenty of fans calling it one of the best RPGs of recent years. The other is frustrated, mostly with the performance, with several viewers asking why Atlus ports keep running unevenly and a few arguing the game never ran perfectly on other platforms either. A smaller thread grumbled that the boxed release is a game-key card rather than the full game on the cartridge.

Viewers also liked the video's format, in which the presenter adds a personal view alongside the written review.

Verdict

If Switch 2 is your only way to play Metaphor: ReFantazio, an 8/10 from Nintendo Life says it's still worth buying, in our reading. The game's strengths survive the port, and an 8/10 for a version with visible technical problems tells you how strong those strengths are.

If you already own it on another platform, this review gives you no reason to buy it again, unless portability matters more to you than a steady frame rate. And if you have a choice of platform and haven't played it yet, the trade-off is simple: Switch 2 gets you the game anywhere, at the cost of the smoothest version of it.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News