Pool of Radiance's re-release: Mortismal praises the fixes, not the game

Mortismal Gaming finished SNEG's new release of the 2001 D&D RPG to 100%. He credits the restoration and still says the game isn't worth playing.

Mia Hart

Overgrown fantasy ruins around a shimmering pool, with scaffolding restoring one archway, illustrating the Pool of Radiance re-release

A good restoration can't fix a game's design, and Mortismal Gaming's review of the new Pool of Radiance: Ruins of Myth Drannor release shows the difference about as clearly as you'll see it. In his 35-minute review, posted on 9 November after finishing the game to 100%, he gives the publisher a lot of credit and the game very little. His description puts it plainly: he "spent entirely too much time on it", and he "did not really enjoy" himself.

If you're weighing up the US$19.99 asking price, that split is the useful part. Here's what he says the re-release fixes, what it can't, and who it might still suit.

What's being reviewed is SNEG's PC release of the 2001 Dungeons & Dragons RPG. According to RPG Site, the original was developed by Stormfront Studios and published by Ubisoft, and this version came to Steam and GOG in November, published by SNEG with Wizards of the Coast. RPG Site lists fixes for numerous original bugs, widescreen support up to 4K, a new action bar and tooltips, full controller support, reworked camera controls, adjustable combat animation speeds and an optional "Legacy" mode for the original look and play.

What the re-release gets right

Mortismal is generous about SNEG's work. Early in the video, around 1:43, he praises the company's preservation efforts, and he walks through the original's reputation for technical trouble, including the uninstaller bug that could wipe a hard drive. His verdict on that side is that SNEG did a great job stabilising and modernising the game, with the combat speed-up a highlight.

It isn't spotless. In the technical section at 6:06 he lists pathfinding problems, party members wandering off and occasional crashes.

Why he still doesn't recommend it

The problems he describes are in the game itself, and no amount of 4K will touch them.

Character creation, from 7:04, is his first big complaint. He finds it thin for a third-edition D&D game, with little of the feat, skill and build choice the ruleset is known for. He argues a Cleric is close to mandatory because so many enemies are undead, and that Intelligence ends up nearly useless.

His harshest words are for the opening dungeon. In the gameplay and world section and the combat chapter at 23:40, he describes a long, repetitive crawl full of stat-draining and incorporeal undead that low-level parties struggle to hurt. He calls it one of the worst dungeon crawls he's played in a CRPG, and he isn't kinder about the final fights, which he finds tedious and badly designed.

There are bright spots. In the story section at 10:30 he finds the plot genuinely interesting, just buried behind that opening, and he rates the itemisation as one of the game's best features. In his conclusion at 33:25, though, the bottom line is that SNEG did right by the game, and the game itself isn't worth playing.

Who it might still be for

That leaves a fairly narrow audience. If you already have a soft spot for Pool of Radiance, or you want to see an early-2000s D&D game running properly on a modern PC, the restoration is the thing you're paying for, and Mortismal's review suggests it delivers. If you're coming in fresh and want a good third-edition RPG to play, his review is a reason to hold off, or at least to try the demo RPG Site says is on the Steam page first.

The comments, as of the video's first six hours, were mostly about the effort, not the game. Viewers thanked him for suffering through it so they didn't have to, admired him for finishing something he didn't enjoy, and gave SNEG credit for making it playable. Several who played it in 2001 remembered the bugs and the grind, and a few hoped modders would overhaul it. Nobody in that early batch really argued with the verdict.

The fair takeaway is the one Mortismal lands on. This is a good release of a frustrating game, and those are two separate decisions. Know which one you're buying for.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News