Skill Up's Big Walk review makes the case for a game that won't hold your hand

Skill Up strongly recommends House House's co-op Big Walk. His one real complaint, no matchmaking, is the point his viewers argued with most.

Finn Tamati

The most interesting argument in Skill Up's review of Big Walk isn't about whether the game is good. He's sure it is: the video's title says he strongly recommends it, and the description calls House House's co-op adventure quietly confident, a game that trusts players to work out how wonderful it is without leading them by the hand. The interesting bit is the one place he wishes it had held on a little tighter, and how quickly his own audience told him no.

It's a 16-minute review, light on spoilers by design. Early on, Skill Up suggests that anyone who already suspects the game is for them should go in knowing as little as possible. That's either good advice or a very polite way of saying stop reading. We'll keep going, carefully.

What follows is a review of his review: what he says Big Walk is doing, where he thinks it stumbles, and where the comments landed by the six-hour mark.

Puzzles you solve by talking

The core idea, as Skill Up describes it from 2:00, is that Big Walk's difficulty sits in communication rather than in the controls. The challenge isn't pulling off a tricky jump. It's getting a group of friends to describe what each of them can see and agree on what to do about it.

He reaches for a comparison around 4:03 that his regulars saw coming: the puzzle encounters remind him of the call-out mechanics in Destiny raids, minus the shooting. A few commenters groaned at another Destiny mention. Others argued it's the most fitting comparison he could have made. Both camps seemed to enjoy themselves.

He also makes a case for the game's slower stretches. In his reading, the downtime between puzzles is deliberate room for the group to just talk, which is a gentle idea for a game, and one that suits a studio that has never seemed in a hurry.

The bush, and the sound of it

The section that will land hardest with Australian players starts at 7:14. Skill Up spends real time on the game's Australian bushland setting, its native plants and its local turns of phrase, and he rates its sense of place very highly. He follows it with the sound design, which he describes as tactile and satisfying to interact with.

That's his judgement, not a measurement, and it's the kind of praise that's hard to check from the outside. It is specific, though, which is more than most landscape compliments manage.

Where he'd change it

The criticisms come from 10:47 and there are two. Progress is tied to the host's save, so the group's journey lives with whoever started the game. And there's no matchmaking, which he sees as a missed chance for strangers to meet and for experienced players to guide new groups through.

This is where the comments pushed back. The most-liked replies on the point argued that matchmaking would be the worst thing for a game like this, because a stranger who already knows the answers could flatten the whole experience. One reply made the sharper point that Big Walk's puzzles are less about finding the answer than about communicating it. Several commenters respected House House for sticking to its design. Others shared the opposite story: groups formed from strangers who swapped join codes on Steam's forums and kept meeting up afterwards. Another said two players are plenty, if one friend is all you've got.

That's crowd mood, not proof of anything. But it does suggest the trade-off Skill Up flags is a real one, and readers will weigh it differently.

Verdict

As a review, it does what a good one should. It tells you early whether to stop watching, explains the design idea clearly, praises specific things and is honest about the two decisions it would undo. The closing section at 13:51 puts his recommendation plainly.

It's for anyone weighing up Big Walk who has a regular group, or wants a sense of whether two or three friends is enough. If you've already decided, take his advice and skip it until you've played. The comments are worth a scroll afterwards, if only to watch a reviewer's one quibble turn into the most interesting debate in the room.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News