Some games are made in a studio. Harold Halibut looks like it was made in a garden shed by very patient people, and that's meant as a compliment. In Nintendo Life's video review of Harold Halibut on Switch 2, presenter Mai Ladyman walks through the handmade adventure and the score it ends up with: a 7 out of 10.
The video is built on Oliver Revolta's written review for Nintendo Life, with Mai adding her own take at the end. This is a summary of their published review, not an assessment from our own play.
The look is the hook
The review opens on the thing everyone notices first (00:23). The characters are built from 3D scans of physical marionettes, and the sets were made by hand. The game comes from Slow Bros, an independent studio in Cologne. Nintendo Life's view is that this stop-motion look is what makes Harold Halibut feel like something you should play.
From there it sets the scene (01:32): Harold, the people living aboard the ship Fedora 1, and a gentle loop of wandering, talking and running errands. In the first half, the review finds that loop works.
Where it drifts
The trouble, by their account, starts around the midpoint (03:43). The second half picks up bloat. There are more repetitive messenger-style errands, and the story slows down. The review puts the main story at about 11 hours and suggests that the back half could have used a trim.
That's a fairly specific complaint, and worth taking at face value. It isn't a case of the game running out of ideas. The balance between story and play tips too far towards the story, and there are long stretches where you don't have much to do.
How the Switch 2 port holds up
The port gets its own section (05:24). Nintendo Life notes camera stutter during zooms and pans, which comes up often in a game this fond of cinematic framing. It also says this version isn't quite as pretty as the game on other platforms. The review doesn't treat either as a dealbreaker.
Mai goes further in her second opinion. She points out frame rate drops in handheld mode, especially in busier areas (08:38), and recommends playing docked for steadier performance (09:23). That's the most practical takeaway in the video for anyone buying it on Switch 2.
The score, and Mai's take
Nintendo Life lands on 7 out of 10, "Good" (06:49). Then Mai's own section takes over (07:01). She has plenty of admiration for the handmade art direction, talks about the voice acting and the story's themes, and still recommends it warmly to people who like stop-motion animation, Wes Anderson films and story-driven adventures (14:31).
Who it's for
Put together, the review describes a game that earns its look and then asks a bit too much patience of you. If you came for the craft, the review suggests you'll get it, and Mai's enthusiasm is hard to miss. If you want a game that keeps your hands busy, the second half is the part to go in warned about. And if you're on Switch 2, their advice is simple: play it docked.
Watch Nintendo Life's full review, or read Oliver Revolta's written review.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes


