The five games Mortismal Gaming found most disappointing in 2026

A reviewer's year-end list of letdowns, and the very different reasons each game fell short.

Riley Brooks

Year-end lists usually celebrate. Mortismal Gaming went the other way. In his rundown of the most disappointing games he's reviewed this year, the reviewer picks out five releases that, as the video's description puts it, couldn't all be winners.

The framing matters. He opens by reflecting on what has been quite the year for gaming before getting to the letdowns. His reasons differ from game to game, which is what makes the list more than a pile-on.

It's a tidy ten minutes, with a chapter for each game, and every entry is one he reviewed in full on the channel earlier in the year. That's worth knowing: these aren't hot takes from a trailer, they're second looks at games he spent real time with and came away from unhappy.

Here's the list, in the order he covers it.

Pool of Radiance: Ruins of Myth Drannor

First up is a name with history. Mortismal considers it a poor game, pointing to frustrating gameplay design, combat he finds lopsided and what he sees as a bad implementation of Dungeons & Dragons. He also notes that the original Pool of Radiance: Ruins of Myth Drannor launched in 2001 with major technical and bug issues of its own, so this is a game whose troubles have some precedent.

GreedFall 2: The Dying World

Next, GreedFall 2. Mortismal's disappointment here is mostly about execution: bugs and balance issues that, in his view, held back a sequel he wanted to like.

Warhammer 40,000: Mechanicus II

The Mechanicus sequel gets one of the sharper verdicts. He feels it's a step down from the first game, with unit abilities that are out of balance and design that feels rushed. That stings more because the sequel adds the Necrons as a new playable faction, which on paper is exactly the kind of addition fans of the first game would want.

Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss

This is the story problem. Mortismal found the central twist obvious within about ten minutes of play, which is a rough outcome for a narrative-led horror game. He adds that the gameplay was weak and that the price, around $40 to $50 at release by his account, was high for what it offers.

High on Life 2

The list closes with High on Life 2, and the complaint is technical. He felt the comedy shooter sequel was badly dragged down by crashes, bugs and resolution issues at launch. Whatever the jokes were like, it was the launch stability that stuck with him, and of the five, it's the entry where his complaint is least about the game's ideas and most about the state it shipped in.

What the list says

In his telling, Pool of Radiance and Mechanicus II disappoint on design and balance, Cthulhu: The Cosmic Abyss on its story, and GreedFall 2 and High on Life 2 on bugs and technical problems. If one of these is on your wishlist, his reasons for each are worth hearing out in full.

He wraps up by inviting viewers to share their own thoughts in the comments, which is a brave thing to ask of a comment section after ten minutes of letdowns.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News