Every so often a game makes it clear it has been paying attention. You try something you think is clever, and the game was already waiting for you. PlayStation Access's latest Checklist is built around exactly that feeling: five presenters, five times a game called them out and, in the video's words, made it personal.
The video runs about 18 minutes, with a chapter for each pick.
The Witcher 3: trying to have it both ways
Chesca opens with The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and the oldest trick in the role-playing book: romancing two characters at once. In this case it's Triss and Yennefer, and the game has a quest waiting for anyone who tries, It Takes Three to Tango. Without giving the scene away, it does not go the way a hopeful Geralt might want. Chesca's point is that she likes the game for it, because it gives both women their own boundaries instead of treating them as prizes.
Undertale: the game keeps score
Rob's pick is Undertale, a game that is famous for remembering what you did. He walks through how it plays with role-playing game habits, and how the route where you kill everything ends in a confrontation with Sans that turns the player's choices back on them. Rob calls that fight a clever way to call the player out, and he's also prepared to argue that its theme, Megalovania, may be the catchiest boss music in games.
The Stanley Parable: the narrator is always watching
Ash goes with The Stanley Parable, which might be the purest example of the theme. Its narrator tells you what to do, and the whole game is about what happens when you don't. Ash is a fan of its dry, self-aware humour and the push and pull between player and narrator.
EA Sports FC: are you sure about that difficulty?
Dave closes the list with the most relatable call-out of all. EA Sports FC keeps suggesting that he drops the difficulty to Professional after he picks World Class. It's a small thing, and the rest of the team clearly finds it very funny. Dave also has strong feelings about puzzle hints in games like Uncharted that pop up when a player is simply taking their time.
Why these moments stick
What ties the five together is that none of them is a punishment in the usual sense. Nobody loses a save file. The game simply shows that it saw what the player did, and that is often more memorable than any boss. A narrator who comments on your choices, a boss who knows what you did on the way there, a cheat screen with a sense of humour: these are small pieces of design that make a game feel like it's looking back at you.
The video ends by asking viewers for their own examples, and that's the right note to finish on. Most players have one.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes


