Marvelous USA's CEO says Switch 2 carts outsold PS5 discs almost 2-to-1 on one game, while PS5 led digital

In a new RPG Site interview, Ken Berry explains why Marvelous USA is stepping back from Xbox discs, why full Switch 2 cartridge releases are getting harder rather than easier, and why retailers now mostly order just enough to cover pre-orders.

Mason Reed

A dim living room at dusk where a glowing abstract handheld console silhouette floats above a coffee table, with red and soft white light trails curling around small luminous cartridge shapes

The most telling number in RPG Site's new interview with Marvelous USA and XSEED Games CEO Ken Berry is about one game, Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion. Berry described it as the only title that launched on all platforms simultaneously, and he told the outlet that the Switch 2 retail edition outsold the PS5 physical version "almost 2-to-1, while on digital the PS5 outsold Switch 2 by 2-to-1."

It was one game with one simultaneous launch, and the results flipped depending on the format. Berry came back to it himself later in the interview, citing "the Daemon X Machina example" when he explained why PS5 has a stronger digital ratio than Nintendo platforms.

A note on sourcing: this article relies on RPG Site's published interview by Mikhail Madnani, dated 16 November. Xarmo couldn't check a first-party Marvelous source directly and hasn't independently verified Berry's statements, so everything below is as RPG Site reports it.

A "Nintendo-heavy" slate, in Berry's words

Some context helps here. Berry told RPG Site that Marvelous USA had three titles (Rune Factory: Guardians of Azuma, Story of Seasons: Grand Bazaar and Daemon X Machina: Titanic Scion) launch within the Switch 2's three-month launch window last year. He said the latest Story of Seasons and Rune Factory games "have been strong on Switch 2, with both titles slightly outselling their original Switch counterparts." He added that the original Switch "still does very well for physical releases," and that the company was happy to see the new console carry on "Nintendo's tradition of a strong retail presence."

Rune Factory: Guardians of Azuma was part of the Switch 2's launch lineup, and Berry said that by his understanding it was the second best-selling third-party game at launch, behind Cyberpunk 2077. He noted that both were full ROM game card releases.

He described the other consoles very differently. Berry said Marvelous USA still tries to release PS5 games physically, but that platform "has a stronger digital ratio for software sales than Nintendo platforms." He explained that the PS5 versions of the company's titles arrived more than six months after the original release, which limited its retail options, so it made those North American disc releases Amazon exclusives. That way, he said, the main store that would stock them anyway was "even more motivated to push for their success." Xbox is a harder case. He told RPG Site that because of Game Pass, "that platform's user base is most comfortable with digital releases so we will likely not be doing many physical releases going forward."

RPG Site's questions set Sony's decision to stop putting new games on discs from 2028 alongside two other changes: Nintendo's 32GB card format and Xbox's disc-to-digital license program. Berry's answer on Sony rested on the company's Nintendo focus. Because its recent lineup has been "so Nintendo-heavy," he said, the change "won't hurt us as much as it would have a few years ago." He added that PlayStation has been vocal about its much higher digital mix, and said he is "cautiously optimistic that it won't affect us too negatively."

Game-Key Cards are winning on cost

RPG Site's interviewer said Marvelous USA has put out more full Switch 2 cartridge releases than almost every other third-party publisher, while the company's European and Japanese arms use Game-Key Cards. Asked whether it had become easier for publishers to bring out "proper game on cart physical releases," Berry said no: "it's getting harder because as Game-Key Cards are getting more and more accepted, the pressure to go for the cheaper option grows."

He also pointed to uncertainty over the price of anything containing computer chips, which he put down to what he called "the ongoing RAMpocalypse." That uncertainty, he said, suggests disc and Game-Key Card releases may end up with "even a greater cost advantage in the future."

That regional split isn't always Marvelous USA's to decide. Asked whether Japanese license holders had ever pushed back on the North American team doing more, Berry said it does "come up from time-to-time." He said the easiest route is to standardize physical releases across all territories, which covers choices like a full ROM game card versus a Game-Key Card and whether the case has a printed insert. He added that "there are times that we are limited to what other territories are doing."

Berry says that for three of Marvelous USA's games, the physical Switch 2 version already costs more. RPG Site mentioned some pushback over Muramasa's higher Switch 2 price. Berry said nothing has changed yet: since then Marvelous USA has announced two more titles, Fate/EXTRA Record and Eternal Anima, where the physical Switch 2 version carries a $10 premium over other retail versions. For all three games, he said, "the most expensive Switch 2 version is the best pre-ordering one." He sees that as a sign fans "are aware of the situation and supportive of what we are doing." Fate/EXTRA Record and Muramasa are also "completely separate products on Switch and Switch 2," so there's no upgrade path between the two versions.

RPG Site also raised overseas players importing North American Switch 2 cartridges. Berry said Marvelous USA's online store ships only within the US ("we are unable to even ship to Canada"), and that he imagines people paying large overseas shipping charges "are very few in number."

Retailers want pre-orders, not restocks

Berry's comments on the overall physical market are mixed. He said "the end of physical media was declared many years ago, but we continued to see strong demand for them, especially the premium SKUs such as limited editions." He said things have shifted over the past year or two. After the first shipment goes out at launch, "even if it sells through to the end consumers really well," Marvelous doesn't get reorders from retailers "the way we used to." Retailers now "want to just order enough units to fulfill pre-orders and then move onto other upcoming new releases," so the company needs to be "more careful about the number of units we manufacture than before."

Demand is also splitting by edition. Berry said pre-orders for special editions "continue to be very strong because people want the additional bonus goods," but weaker demand for base versions offsets that, since "the convenience of purchasing digitally is hard to beat when the main interest is just in playing the game itself." Demand for older titles "has dropped considerably," which he said is "surely why retailers have shifted" toward pushing pre-orders.

Reprints don't fill that gap. Berry said Marvelous USA doesn't reprint much, because the main outlets for older titles are Amazon and some distributors. He said "we often get approached by distributors to reprint older titles," but the pricing they offer "rarely makes it worth the effort."

Muramasa on Steam, and no more catch-up ports

On Muramasa, Berry said the PC version came out of "mutual consultation between Marvelous and Vanillaware," and that "the PC port is being done internally by Vanillaware." RPG Site's interviewer described it as Vanillaware's first Steam release as far as they were aware.

Berry was blunt about bringing older games to new platforms. When RPG Site's interviewer said they hoped for Switch 2 releases of games such as Senran Kagura and Uppers, Berry pointed out that those titles are still available on PC and most are on at least one modern console. He said the extra sales from a straight port "almost surely wouldn't recoup the investment needed, so afraid the chances are extremely slim." On mobile, he said Google's marketing support helped Moonlight Peaks reach "higher sales than expected for a premium title on mobile" on Google Play. He said Marvelous and developer Little Chicken "may need to explore" an iOS release at some point.

Over on ResetEra, the moderator who posted the interview asked the question the PS5 and Xbox answers leave hanging: if PS5 steps out of discs but Xbox stays, do collectors and publishers "gravitate to supporting the platform more," or does "all that energy just go into propping up Switch even more?" Going by what Berry told RPG Site about Xbox, Marvelous USA at least isn't planning to move that way.

Mason's take: The Daemon X Machina split is why I think this interview matters beyond one publisher. It explains a lot of what Berry says about discs, cartridges and retailers: Nintendo players still buy boxes, PS5 leans digital, and Berry says Xbox players are most comfortable with digital. Berry also told RPG Site that the ability of Nintendo Switch 2 Edition games to put both the full Switch 2 version and a scaled-down Switch version on one cartridge is "not talked about enough." I think he's right, and I'd go further: it's the strongest case anyone has for full cartridges, because original Switch owners can buy now and not worry about upgrading later. Berry's description of Fate/EXTRA Record and Muramasa as "completely separate products on Switch and Switch 2" with "no upgrade path" suggests those two games won't be using that single-card approach, though. And on the pricier Switch 2 versions, the evidence Berry offers for fan support is that the most expensive Switch 2 version is "the best pre-ordering one." If cheaper formats keep pulling ahead on cost, as Berry suggests they might, my reading is that full cartridges end up relying on a shrinking group of collectors. My bet is that more mid-sized publishers move to Game-Key Cards over the next year, and that Marvelous USA's $10 premium lasts only as long as its most loyal fans keep paying it.

Sources

More from Xarmo News