Most channels mark an anniversary with a montage. Mortismal Gaming marked its eleventh with 21 minutes that read more like an annual report, one where the auditor is also the subject. The numbers get a section. So does college. The description calls the channel, started on a whim, "one of the most consequential decisions of my life", which is about as much sentiment as the video allows itself.
The part most worth a stranger's time comes early, and it's about what a view is.
The number that changed under everyone's feet
At 3:53 Mortismal turns to a change YouTube made in late August. TechCrunch reported that from August 24 a view would count as soon as a video started playing, with the older measure renamed Engaged views and kept in Analytics. YouTube said it wouldn't affect earnings or Partner Program eligibility, and that creators had wanted an end to "metric confusion".
Mortismal's account is a working reviewer's: the raw view counts went up, the time people actually spent watching did not move much, and given the choice the older system was better. This is someone with a professional interest in knowing whether a number means anything, watching it get bigger for reasons unrelated to the work.
There are figures behind the suspicion, though they come from an interested party. Tubefilter reported in September that the creator advertising platform Agentio had looked at more than 75,000 videos from its network and found only about six in 10 public views also counted as Engaged Views. For gaming, the rate was 56%. A channel like this one, which depends on readers trusting its judgement, is not obviously helped by a counter that flatters everybody equally.
The other thing that happened this year
The video's second act is less expected. At 7:28 Mortismal gets to college. Having spent years as a full-time YouTuber, they have enrolled as an adult, and they connect that decision to a difficult start in life, including homelessness as a teenager. It's told plainly, without much of a pause for effect, and it isn't the sort of thing that needs dressing up here either.
The practical detail is funnier. Five classes in a first semester, it turns out, is a poor match for September's game releases, and from 10:11 the plan is to stagger future courses. Anyone who has watched a reviewer whose brand is finishing everything can guess how that autumn went.
Seven years, give or take
The closing stretch, from 15:30, is the quietest and the most candid. Mortismal says a typical YouTube channel lasts around seven years, and that it pays to be ready for things to change. Their channel is four years past that. They are also not especially cheerful about the wider game industry, and they mention wanting to cover the next Divinity from Larian, along with a second bucket-list game they keep to themselves.
Put those together and the view-count complaint reads differently. It isn't a grumble about a metric. It's someone who has outlasted the average, is building a second option at a community college, and would like the dashboard to keep telling the truth while they do it.
The comments were warm and largely unbothered by analytics. Viewers congratulated the channel on eleven years, wished Mortismal luck with the classes and the march towards 500,000 subscribers, and one running joke asked for a college review after 100% completion. Five classes, by the sound of it, is already most of the way there.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes
