Small controllers live or die on what they leave out, and Russ from Retro Game Corps reckons the Xbox Nano leaves out a bit too much. In his review of the Xbox Nano Controller, he calls it a neat little novelty, but says the compromised controls, the small battery and Xbox's new cloud gaming limits make it "relatively inessential".
This is a summary of his published review, not a hands-on test of our own. For the launch details, see Xarmo's News on the Nano's preorders.
Small, light and a bit hollow
Russ starts with the unboxing and first impressions (00:25). He bought his Nano from the Microsoft Store for $50, and he lines it up against an SNES pad and a standard Xbox controller. His first reaction is to the weight. He finds it so light that it feels hollow and a bit cheap for its size.
He then walks through the design (01:24). There's no rumble and no headphone jack, and the battery is built in rather than swappable.
Where the shrinking hurts
The chapter on compromised controls (02:40) is the heart of the review.
Sticks. He rates the analog sticks as fine for travel, but not something he'd choose for regular play. He also points out they use standard potentiometers rather than Hall effect sensors.
D-pad. This is where he's harshest. He finds it mushy and short on pivot, and calls it the worst control on the device. He tries it across Contra, Celeste and Street Fighter III: 3rd Strike, and it doesn't win him over.
Comfort. His view is that it works in a pinch, but for long sessions he'd rather hold a full-sized controller.
Software, connections and the cloud
There's some good news in the middle. He shows remapping and firmware updates in the Xbox Accessories app (09:00). He then tests connections across an Xbox Series S, a Windows handheld, a Steam Deck and Android (09:57). His one complaint there is that pairing under SteamOS was buggy, with a pairing light that kept blinking and trouble reconnecting.
The cloud chapter (12:32) is where the Nano's best trick runs into Xbox policy. Russ shows it connecting to Xbox Cloud Gaming directly over Wi-Fi, which he says cuts input latency. Then he runs through the new monthly cloud gaming caps on Game Pass: 15 hours on Ultimate, 10 on Premium and five on Essential. Xarmo covered those hour limits when Xbox announced them. Russ isn't a fan of the caps, and they shrink the case for a controller built around streaming.
Battery and teardown
In the battery and teardown chapter (15:47) he measures roughly five hours from a charge, then opens the Nano up and finds a 500mAh cell. He argues Microsoft should have fitted a bigger battery, which he thinks would have helped both the battery life and the hollow feel.
Verdict
Russ sums up (17:41) with a clear call. At $50 he doesn't recommend the Nano unless you have a specific mobile or cloud use for it. For retro games he points to the 8BitDo SN30 Pro instead.
That's useful framing. Nothing in his review says the Nano is broken. He just thinks the price asks for more than the hardware gives back. If you want an official Xbox pad that streams straight from the cloud and fits in a jacket pocket, it still does that. If the D-pad matters to you, his review is the one to watch first.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes

