Moon's Warcraft 3 heroes take on Last's Brood War army in a StarCraft 2 arcade mod

LowkoTV casts a five-game show match in which Warcraft 3 legend Moon takes his heroes into a StarCraft 2 arcade mod against Brood War champion Last. The result is less a fair fight than a collision of two design philosophies.

Finn Tamati

Every real-time strategy argument eventually lands on the same daydream: what if the two Blizzard classics could just play each other? In a new video, LowkoTV casts a five-game show match that does exactly that. Moon, the Warcraft 3 player the description calls the legend "they call the fifth race", takes on Last, a StarCraft: Brood War Terran champion, in a StarCraft 2 arcade mod that drops Warcraft 3 on one side of the map and StarCraft 1 on the other. Lowko calls it one of the strangest show matches he has ever cast, and it is hard to argue with him.

The pitch is simple and slightly unhinged. Moon gets heroes, creeping, lumber and the day and night cycle. Last gets Brood War units. Over five games, Moon plays Undead, Orc, Human and Night Elf against Last's Terran and Protoss, and the question the video sets itself, in the description's words, is whether Warcraft 3 heroes that keep levelling up can hold off siege tanks, spider mines and Reavers. According to the description, Moon practised the mod for three weeks before the series.

Two games that never met

The interesting part isn't who wins. It's watching two design philosophies discover each other in real time. Warcraft 3 is built around a handful of powerful heroes who grow stronger by fighting neutral monsters. Brood War is built around economy, positioning and armies large enough to fill a screen. Lowko says early on that he finds these cross-game mods entertaining whatever their balance, because the interactions between such different designs are the point.

Game 1 sets the tone: Undead against Terran, with Moon's heroes creeping camps while Last digs in behind bunkers, minefields and siege tanks. It is a long, grinding opener, and it shows how differently the two sides think about space. One wants to own the map with a few units that matter enormously; the other wants to own it with a wall of tanks.

Adjustments

From Game 2, Orc against Protoss, the series becomes a story about adaptation. Last's Protoss leans on cannons and Dark Templar; Moon answers with Warcraft's shop items and his own heroes. In Game 3, Human against Protoss, Moon uses a Goblin Zeppelin to carry heroes straight into Last's mineral line, a move that only makes sense in a world where a neutral shop sells air transport.

Lowko's read, offered as the cast goes on, is that Moon's key adjustment after the opener was to stop letting the Brood War side build its economy freely and to choke it early instead. That is commentary, not a statistic, but it is the thread that ties the middle of the series together.

Game 4 brings Night Elf against Terran, and the best single interaction of the video: Treants summoned by Moon's Keeper of the Grove wander into Last's tank lines, and the splash damage lands on Last's own units. It is the kind of thing neither game's designers could have planned for, because neither game had the other in mind.

Game 5 returns to Undead against Terran, a rematch of the opener. Moon changes his build, and late in the cast Lowko argues that high-level Warcraft 3 heroes with their ultimate abilities become close to impossible for a StarCraft army to stop. The score is in the video; it isn't in this piece.

The comment section's verdict

The comments posted in the first six hours split neatly into two camps. The first is busy naming the hybrid, and nearly every Star Wars pun you can think of turns up at least once. The second is busy rebalancing it. Several viewers argue the mod leans too far towards the Warcraft side, with heroes too hard to kill and trades that look lopsided, and they offer fixes ranging from scaling Warcraft units down to giving the StarCraft races heroes of their own. Others simply want more of it, with requests for a three-way match that adds a StarCraft 2 player to the mix.

That split feels about right. As a contest, a mod like this was never going to be perfectly fair. As a story, it works anyway: two players at the top of two different games, one with weeks of practice in the strange new middle ground, meeting in a place neither game was built to go.

The full cast runs a little under two hours, with chapters for each game in the description, so it is easy to jump straight to whichever matchup sounds most absurd.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News