Warren Spector says GTA 6 shows great games need time and money, and hopes it's the last of its kind

The Deus Ex veteran congratulated the GTA 6 team, then said its billion-dollar cost isn't a model anyone else can, or probably should, copy while thousands of developers are out of work.

Jax Mercer

A neon-lit coastal city skyline at dusk, glowing palm silhouettes and blurred car light trails on a wet highway, warm pink and orange sky reflecting off ocean water.

Warren Spector reacted to GTA 6's launch with two points that pull in opposite directions. One: games that matter need time and money. Two: he hopes this one, at about a billion dollars, is "the last of its kind".

Spector is the retired designer who helped create Deus Ex, System Shock and Ultima Underworld. He made both points in a LinkedIn post, which Time Extension and Shacknews both covered. We couldn't check the original post directly, so every quote below is as those two outlets report it.

The praise

He started nicely. "First, congratulations to everyone who worked on GTA 6," Spector said, according to Time Extension. "It looks like it will be a high point of sorts for our medium and our business."

Shacknews says he congratulated the Rockstar Games team on a successful launch. Time Extension notes the game arrived after 13 years of development, a huge budget and an intense marketing campaign.

The catch

Then he got to the bill. As quoted by Time Extension, Spector said the game's "billion-dollar development cost and an undoubtedly crazy marketing budget don't represent a business model anyone else can or probably should emulate."

"That's especially true when thousands of developers are out of work," he continued. "A billion dollars pays for a lot of games and a lot of salaries. Personally I'd rather have hundreds of games and full employment than one game no matter how amazing it is."

Note the "probably" in there. On the business model, at least, he hedges.

Key word: potential

Both outlets carry his main design point: no game that matters ships on time and/or on budget. Shacknews quotes the lead-in: "the sure success of GTA 6 proves a point I've made for years." Time Extension quotes him pushing harder: "I'll say again — a billion dollars! And at least a year late on its original ship date."

Both also run the line that matters most: "Give a game the time and money to prove its potential (key word, potential) and you have a chance of making something great. Underfund a game or force it out the door before it's ready guaranteed failure no matter how much potential it has."

So "delays make games good" is the wrong reading. The argument is lopsided. In his telling, time and money only buy a chance at greatness, while starving a project guarantees failure. Shacknews notes that many legendary developers have shared the sentiment over the years. The best-known version is the line "a delayed game is eventually good, but a rushed game is forever bad", often attributed to Shigeru Miyamoto.

Last of its kind

His ending is firmer than the hedged business-model line. Time Extension says he concludes by congratulating the team but says that, ultimately, it should never happen again. In his words, per Time Extension: "Ambition and innovation are necessary for the medium to reach its potential. I just hope GTA 6 is the last of its kind even if it's the best we have to offer."

Jax's take: Spector's two arguments rub against each other, and in the excerpts the outlets ran he doesn't say where the line sits. If a billion dollars and a game "at least a year late" are what make GTA 6 look like "a high point of sorts", then "give it time and money" has no obvious ceiling. The question every other studio actually needs answered is how much is enough. My bet is publishers hear "great games cost a billion", skip the "key word, potential" bit completely and do the opposite of what he's asking.

Sources

More from Xarmo News