World of Warcraft: Forever's economy hit by a dungeon gold exploit

Eurogamer reports that a loot table bug in the Blackmaw Hold dungeon left some players with thousands of gold before Blizzard quietly hotfixed it. Now players want the gold taken back.

Mason Reed

A glowing pile of golden coins spilling across a dark stone floor inside a misty fantasy dungeon, with warm torchlight and drifting embers against cool blue shadows.

According to Eurogamer, Blizzard has already fixed the bug in World of Warcraft: Forever's Blackmaw Hold dungeon. What it hasn't said is what happens to the gold the bug already paid out. In a report published on 17 November, Eurogamer calls it the game's "first economic nightmare." It says a dungeon exploit left some players with thousands of gold while "the vast majority of players are barely above their first hundred." One set of broken loot tables has split the player base into two very unequal groups, and that gap is the real story here.

We couldn't check the original source directly, so everything below is as Eurogamer reports it.

What went wrong in Blackmaw Hold

Eurogamer says the exploit sits in the new Blackmaw Hold dungeon, which opens with several packs of non-elite enemies that are easy to kill. According to Eurogamer, the loot drop tables for those enemies were wrong before the hotfix and paid out far more gold than they should have. Eurogamer reports that players who noticed kept quiet about it. They would run in, clear the early mobs and reset the dungeon every hour.

Eurogamer reports that every class could do this. Citing Twitch streamer Ziqo, it says the method let players farm hundreds of gold in a few hours. According to Eurogamer, Ziqo was seen streaming with more than 4,000 gold and claims other streamers ended up with even more. Eurogamer says Blizzard hotfixed the bug "quickly and quietly," but not before an unknown number of players cashed in.

To show the scale, Eurogamer uses a benchmark from the original Classic World of Warcraft, not from Forever. That benchmark is the expert riding skill, which Eurogamer calls one of the most expensive things a player is likely to buy in Classic, at around 900 gold. It describes the skill as a long savings goal and a real milestone for a character. Eurogamer doesn't say what anything costs in Forever, so treat the 900 gold as a Classic yardstick and not a Forever price. By Eurogamer's account, players using the exploit could have paid that amount several times over after just a few days of grinding. Eurogamer doesn't do this sum, but by our own arithmetic Ziqo's reported 4,000 gold is more than four times that Classic figure.

Why a few rich players matter to everyone else

It's tempting to shrug this off as a handful of people getting their mounts early, and Eurogamer anticipates exactly that reaction. Its answer is that MMO economies are shared, so a small group with a lot of gold can push prices up for everyone. According to Eurogamer, they could buy every listing of a rare resource on the auction house and relist it at a markup. They could also outbid other players for rare bind-on-equip items, which raises what sellers expect to get for those drops. Eurogamer says the combined effect is inflationary and could make a server's economy more expensive faster than it would otherwise get. Even if that effect turns out to be mild, it adds, exploiters could gear out several characters without putting in the hours, or outbid the rest of the community on the Black Market Auction House.

Here's my analysis, which isn't something Eurogamer or Blizzard has said. The damage from a bug like this lasts longer than the bug does. In a shared economy, gold that arrives early doesn't stay with the people who farmed it. It feeds into the prices everyone else pays, and those prices become the baseline people work from afterwards. That means a few days of broken loot tables could shape a server long after the hotfix. Blizzard's response is also an early test of how it plans to police Forever, and whatever it does here will likely be the precedent players point to next time.

Players want more than a hotfix

Eurogamer reports that players on Reddit and the official World of Warcraft forums are asking Blizzard to go further than the hotfix. A forum user named Maya wants the gold removed and the exploiters banned: "Remove the gold or I and many others will just quit. This is worse than the bots at this point."

Eurogamer also quotes Reddit user Flnrodi, writing about streamers who used the exploit. Flnrodi said Ziqo had done the farming off stream, and argued that this showed it was understood as an exploit: "The fact that he did this all offstream says enough that [Ziqo] (and others) knew that this is not intended and 100 percent considered an exploit. Personally, I think there should be some kind of punishment and definitely all the gold [should be] revoked."

The case against punishment

Eurogamer also lays out the other side. "The counter argument against punitive measures is that these players didn't cheat," it writes. According to Eurogamer, they didn't buy gold from real-money traders or use outside tools. Eurogamer says they reached roughly level 55, ran a dungeon and killed the same mobs over and over. Eurogamer allows that flagging the exploit as soon as they found it would have been a good thing. It also argues that once other players at the same level were using it, with no clear rule on whether that's punishable, joining in was arguably in a player's own interest.

Eurogamer says that as of its writing, Blizzard hadn't given any official word on its plans beyond fixing the exploit. Eurogamer suggests that because of Blackmaw Hold's level requirement, the number of exploiters can't be very large. It also says that gains this big this fast should make them easy to find. According to Eurogamer, rolling accounts back to their pre-exploit gold "certainly appears to be a popular option," and it calls whether Blizzard does that, or something harsher, "the big question."

Mason's take: Blizzard should take the gold back and stop short of blanket bans. This was a bug in Blizzard's own loot tables that some players quietly used, and that doesn't make those players blameless. Even Eurogamer, while making the case against punishment, grants that flagging the exploit straight away would have been a good thing. And at least one player, Flnrodi, reads Ziqo's off-stream farming as a sign that it was known to be unintended, though that's one Reddit user's claim, not something Blizzard has established. A rollback handles both sides of the problem. It removes the reward and repairs the economy without Blizzard having to work out who knew what. Leaving the gold in place is the option I'd worry about most, because it would tell every Forever player that gaming the economy has no lasting cost. To me, Eurogamer's case against punishment is the most persuasive part of its piece, and it's an argument for skipping the bans, not for keeping the gold. As of Eurogamer's report, Blizzard hasn't said which way it's going, and that silence is the first thing that needs to end.

Sources

More from Xarmo News