Sleep or shut down? What to do with a mini PC when you walk away

An Engadget guide says you'll probably use sleep more on a mini PC, though shutdown has its benefits. Its power figures put running one around the clock at about $16 a year.

Mason Reed

A small, sleek box-shaped computer on a dark wooden shelf glows with a faint blue standby light, with soft ambient light from a nearby screen in a dim, quiet room at night.

The power menu on a mini PC looks like a small decision. A new Engadget guide by Calvin Wankhede suggests it mostly stops being one once you look at the electricity numbers. The subhead gives the short version: "You'll probably use sleep more, but shutdown has its benefits." The longer version ends somewhere more interesting, with a mini PC that never gets turned off at all. Xarmo couldn't check the original directly, so everything below is as Engadget reports it.

The question comes up because a mini PC is close to a laptop without being one. Engadget says many mini PCs contain "laptop-grade hardware under the hood," and that in many cases they "use relatively efficient hardware compared to traditional PCs." According to the outlet, the only differences from a laptop are that mini PCs have no battery and have "beefier cooling hardware that tends to result in better sustained performance." The missing piece is the lid. As Engadget puts it, "unlike a laptop where you can simply close its lid and put it away, a mini PC asks you to choose between sleep, shutdown and sometimes hibernation options when you're done using it."

Which option is right depends on what the machine is for. Engadget says mini PCs don't offer "the performance or expansion capabilities of a full desktop," but calls them "excellent everyday computers" and says their small footprint makes them "ideal for a home server or a media center." Those two jobs lead to two different answers.

Sleep for short breaks, and often for long ones

For the mini PC on a desk, Engadget's rule of thumb is that "sleep is better for short periods, while shutdown allows you to unplug the mini PC." If you're stepping away for a few minutes, sleep wins because you can resume within seconds. After a full shutdown, the outlet says, you'll "have to wait a couple of minutes before reaching the desktop," even with a modern SSD.

Longer breaks are where the trade-off shows up. Wankhede says they would "still personally favor sleep mode, as it allows you to keep your programs open for later." The cost, according to Engadget, is that a sleeping mini PC still draws some power, "even if it's considerably less than when the computer is up and running." The outlet puts that at "about one to four watts of power, which will barely register on most power bills." If you don't care about keeping programs running, a full shutdown lets you unplug the mini PC altogether. That "can be valuable if you live in a region with high electricity rates," the guide says, but "it's not worth worrying over in most cases."

Shutdown keeps one job regardless. Engadget says a full shutdown, which closes open applications, "can be useful to give your computer a fresh start from time to time."

Hibernation splits the difference

For "the best of both worlds," Engadget points to Windows' hibernation feature. The outlet explains that hibernation saves the state of open programs to disk before the PC powers down completely, then restores the session, including open applications and documents, when it starts again. Because hibernation is "similar to a full shutdown," you can unplug the computer from the wall. The catch is that "booting a hibernated PC takes longer than resuming from sleep."

The guide also addresses the old worry that leaving a computer half-awake wears it out. The small amount of power running through the components in sleep "won't cause any major damage," Engadget says, "unless you experience frequent brownouts or similar electrical anomalies." According to the outlet, capacitors and other parts were much more sensitive to constant power in earlier decades, "but that's no longer the case these days."

Or just never turn it off

The guide's last section skips the power menu entirely, and it's the part that explains the rest. Wankhede writes that they have two mini PCs tucked away in a closet and a drawer. One runs "a self-hosted smart home server," and the other serves media from their personal collection. Both have to be ready at a moment's notice, because "nobody in my family wants to wait several minutes for a movie to load." Wankhede adds that they can stream media from the mini PC over the internet even when away from home.

What makes that practical is the power draw. According to Engadget, "mini PCs consume very little power, especially when you aren't running a performance-hungry application," and at idle, mini PCs are "particularly good at keeping power consumption low." The outlet says power draw generally rises with CPU load, and GPU load if the machine has a GPU. At idle, a typical mini PC draws "between 10W and 15W from the wall," depending on its processor, memory and storage. Extra SSDs, and especially hard drives, push that up, but only by "a few watts."

Engadget's worked example: a mini PC averaging about 10 watts at idle uses "just over 87 kilowatt hours (kWh) annually." At what the outlet calls the average residential US electricity rate of $0.18 per kWh, that comes to "around $16 a year" to keep it powered 24/7. The outlet notes that the real cost will be higher depending on how often the machine handles demanding tasks.

The math holds up. By Xarmo's arithmetic, 10 watts across the 8,760 hours in a year is 87.6 kWh, or about $15.77 at $0.18. Applying the same rate to Engadget's other figures, the top of its 10W-to-15W idle range comes to about $24 a year, and a machine left asleep around the clock at one to four watts comes to roughly $1.60 to $6.30. Those are estimates built only on the outlet's numbers, not measurements.

Mason's take: The $16 figure matters more than the one-to-four watts for sleep. At that price, the box in the closet stops being a computer you manage and becomes an appliance you forget about, like a router, and the sleep-or-shutdown question really only applies to the mini PC on your desk. Even there, shutting down every time looks like a habit from an era when it made sense. If sleep costs a few dollars a year and doesn't hurt the hardware, waiting for a full boot every time costs you more. Shut down when Windows starts acting up, use hibernation if you really want the plug out, and otherwise let the thing sleep.

Sources

More from Xarmo News