For most people, a $30 controller is now enough, and the extra $170 only makes sense if you live on a gamepad. That's my takeaway from PC Gamer's video comparison, in which Andy and Jacob spend a couple of weeks with the Razer Wolverine V4 Pro and the GameSir Nova Lite 2 and try to work out how much controller you actually need.
The useful part is that the cheap one doesn't lose on the feature that matters most. Here's how I'd make the call.
What the money does and doesn't buy
Start with stick drift, the classic way controllers die. Both of these pads are designed to avoid it. The Razer uses capacitive anti-drift sticks, Windows Central reports, while PC Gamer's own review says the GameSir's Hall effect sticks lower the chance of drift appearing later. Jacob says at 6:48 that drift resistance is now a must on any controller. Since a $30 pad has it too, that's no longer a reason to pay more.
The GameSir is also wireless. PC Gamer lists 2.4GHz for PC and Bluetooth for Android, iOS and Switch, plus a mechanical D-pad, trigger stops and programmable rear buttons, for $30 / £30. It called the controller "a new benchmark for budget gamepads" and gave it 87.
So what does $200 get you? Mostly feel, inputs and speed:
- More extra buttons. Windows Central counts four removable rear buttons and two claw-grip bumpers, against the GameSir's two extra buttons.
- Better buttons. Andy singles out the crisp response of the Razer's mecha-tactile switches at 3:06. The GameSir's face buttons are plain membrane, PC Gamer says.
- Polling rate. Windows Central lists up to 8,000Hz on PC, against 1,000Hz on the GameSir. Its own reviewer says they'd probably swap that for something else as a consumer, and that it's aimed at "Pro" gamers.
- Battery. Razer claims up to 27 hours, and Windows Central estimates 20 to 24 in practice. PC Gamer measured about eight and a half hours on the GameSir.
The trade-offs on each side
Neither is flawless. The GameSir is slick and plain: PC Gamer says it doesn't have much grip, its shoulder buttons are a little small and its software is basic. Those are fair sacrifices at $30, but you'd feel them over long sessions.
The Razer's catch is what's missing at that price. Windows Central flags no charging dock and no Bluetooth, and suggests other controllers may suit a regular player better. Andy accepts at 18:29 that $200 is a lot, while arguing that the quality justifies it for people who use one every day. That's a reasonable case, but note who it's for.
There's also timing. Windows Central says an Xbox Elite Series 3 is rumoured to be close, so I'd treat that as a rumour, not a plan, but it's one more reason not to rush a big purchase.
Which one should you buy?
Use this simple test:
- You mostly play on mouse and keyboard. Get the cheap one. Jacob makes this exact case at 22:38, and PC Gamer's review says the same.
- You play on a controller most days, especially fast multiplayer. The Razer starts to make sense, if you can live without a dock.
- You want a lot of customisation or also play on your phone. Neither fits perfectly. The GameSir has Bluetooth but little customisation, and the Razer is the reverse.
If you're not sure which group you're in, you're probably in the first one. Buy the $30 pad, and if you wear it out, you'll have your answer.
From the creators
Watch the video
Reporting notes
