Checking GTA 6's user score this week? Look at the PlayStation Store before Metacritic. According to Dexerto, only players who own the game can rate it there, and GTA 6 holds 4.84 out of 5. Push Square says that rating is based on 170,000 reviews and is "probably a better reflection of how the community feels".
Metacritic is a mess right now. Dexerto reports that GTA 6 and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake are both copping waves of zero-score user reviews there, and fans of each game appear to be targeting the other. Xarmo couldn't load Metacritic directly to check the live numbers, so every figure below comes from Dexerto and Push Square.
Two record holders, one feud
The rivalry has a neat bit of history behind it. Dexerto notes that GTA 6 launched with a 99 Metascore, which ties the original 1998 Ocarina of Time for the highest critic score in Metacritic's history. Dexerto describes critics as near-unanimous in their praise.
Users are another matter. Push Square reported on 21 November that GTA 6's user score had dropped to 5.4, which puts it in Metacritic's "Mixed or Average" band. In its later report, Dexerto said the PS5 user score had fallen to 5.0, with thousands of negative ratings arriving within a day of launch.
So one game is sitting at 4.84 out of 5 from owners and around half marks on Metacritic.
The accounts doing it
According to Dexerto, some of the accounts giving GTA 6 a zero have barely rated anything else. On some of those profiles, the only other game is Nintendo's Ocarina of Time remake, and it got a perfect 10.
Dexerto quotes one review that blasts Rockstar for "making us wait 13 years for an 80-100$ (maybe invisible or stolen) code in a box that only runs at 30 FPS" and calls the game "a buggy mess at launch". Another, which Dexerto says took aim at the game's digital-only price, ends with: "This is the beginning of the end for Sony and Rockstar."
Zelda takes fire too
It's going both ways. Dexerto reports that the Ocarina of Time remake launched on Switch 2 on 5 November, and by 8 November it had a 9.6 user score, the highest in Metacritic's history. That score has since slipped to 9.0, and Dexerto says a fresh batch of zeros has arrived, aimed squarely at Nintendo fans.
"Fan forever GTA 6. Go cry fans of Zelda," reads one, according to Dexerto. Another zero-score review quoted by the outlet is more upfront about the motive: "Y'all losers review bombing GTA 6."
Nobody can say who started it. Dexerto says GTA 6 fans claim Nintendo players flooded Rockstar's game first, while some Zelda fans insist it went the other way.
Not all of it is the feud
Some of the negative GTA 6 reviews are actual complaints about the game. Dexerto says some players have issues with the 30fps cap on consoles, frame rate drops and open-world bugs. Others have objected to the optional romance system and claimed the game has gone "woke".
Push Square saw the same themes. It said many of the zeros call 30fps "unplayable", say the series has gone "woke" and claim the "story is horrible". Push Square did single out one fair point: a reviewer who doesn't like the life-sim elements and prefers the "power fantasy" of older games.
One review quoted by Push Square goes after Rockstar's relationship with the press: "Good thing Rockstar doesn't blacklist user ratings like they do critics." Push Square rejects that idea and points out that Rockstar put GTA 6 in the hands of more than 150 critics.
Why Metacritic gets hit and the PS Store doesn't
It comes down to one check. Dexerto notes that, unlike the PlayStation Store, Metacritic doesn't require users to prove they own a game before rating it. Push Square makes the same point: on Metacritic, you don't need to own a game to rate it.
Jax's take: If you're using user scores to decide on GTA 6, skip Metacritic's this week and check the PS Store rating instead. With no ownership check, Metacritic is the easy place for two fanbases to have a go at each other, and real gripes like the 30fps cap get buried in the noise. I don't think that score will be worth reading until Metacritic starts checking who actually owns the game.
Reporting notes
