Underkeep, the turn-based answer to 90s dungeon crawlers: what Mortismal's first look shows

Mortismal's first look at Underkeep, a new party-based grid dungeon crawler from Rake in Grass, finds a fun, deeper-than-it-looks tribute to the 90s with turn-based fights, an automap and one niggle about item requirements.

Ollie Grant

A stone dungeon corridor of square tiles with a glowing map hovering above

There's a particular kind of game that used to arrive on several floppy disks: four adventurers, a corridor drawn one square at a time, and a strong chance you'd be reaching for graph paper by the second floor. Underkeep is a new one of those, with a few modern mercies. Mortismal Gaming took a first look at it in an eight-minute video on 7 November. The video's description calls the game "an enjoyable tribute to the dungeon crawling classics of the 90s".

The game itself is from Rake in Grass, and its Steam page lists a 5 November release, a party of four adventurers, turn-based combat and a free demo. Mortismal says up front, early in the video, that this is a look rather than a full review.

A party, a grid and something slightly wrong underneath

The premise is the classic one: a party heads down into a dangerous place. What Mortismal picks out from about the 52-second mark is the tone. He finds an eldritch, slightly disconcerting atmosphere running under the friendly art, and thinks it helps the game stand out. He's also candid that the visual style won't be for everyone.

Character creation, from 1:45, offers a range of fantasy classes and races, each race with its own perks. His example is the Stoneborn, who can't wear body armour and get natural armour bonuses instead, which is the sort of rule the old games loved: a trade-off that only makes sense four floors later.

Squares, maps and turns

Movement is grid-based, square by square, the way the genre always was. The big concession to modern patience is an automap, shown around 4:44. The graph paper can stay in the drawer.

Combat is where Underkeep parts company with some of its ancestors. It's turn-based, with front and back rows that decide who can hit whom, and Mortismal walks through how it works from 5:36. Around that sits the housekeeping: resting, eating, quests from a village and crafting.

His one real reservation, at about 4:22, is about gear. Items come with stat requirements that he finds somewhat arbitrary, and he suggests class restrictions might have been the cleaner way to do it. It's a small complaint, but a familiar one in a genre where a good sword can sit in the backpack for hours.

The verdict, and the crowd

His overall view, near the end, is that Underkeep is a fun game with more depth than it first appears to have.

The comments were about as warm as comment sections get. Viewers kept naming the games it reminded them of, Eye of the Beholder above all, along with Lands of Lore, Might and Magic and Grimrock. Several said they'd played the demo or bought the game already and were enjoying it, and some welcomed the switch to turns over the old real-time scramble. The one recurring grumble echoed Mortismal's own: item stat requirements.

That's a nice place for a tribute to land. The old dungeon crawlers asked a lot of their players, and the people who remember that most fondly seem pleased to find one that asks a little less.

Watch the video

Sources

More from Xarmo News