The mechanics games hide to help you: coyote time, generous health bars and enemies that miss on purpose

Coyote time, health bars that hold more than they show and enemies that always miss their first shot: the help games hide from you, as developers described it when designer Jennifer Scheurle asked.

Finn Tamati

A cliff edge with a faint platform of light extending past it over a misty canyon

In 1995 Bullfrog released a sci-fi racing game called Hi Octane, with a big truck, a speedy hover-car and a WipEout-style land jet, plus a stats display to tell them apart. According to the game's designer Alex Trowers, as designer Jennifer Scheurle told a Game Developers Conference audience in 2018, they all handled exactly the same. Players, it seems, never twigged. "The different shape and the look of the vehicles was enough, in combination with the stats display, that players would never doubt the system," Scheurle said, in Game Developer's report on the talk.

Hi Octane is the extreme case, but it belongs to a large and mostly invisible family: the mechanics games keep quiet about because they work better unseen. Most of them exist to help you. They forgive your timing, keep you alive a little longer than the screen admits, and teach enemies some manners. The short answer to "does this game secretly go easy on me?" is often yes, and on purpose.

Much of what's known about them came out of one question. In September 2017 Scheurle, then game design lead at Earthlight, asked on Twitter for hidden mechanics designed to give players a particular feeling, and, as PC Gamer reported, developers queued up to confess.

Forgiving your timing

The best-known trick has the best name. In platformers like Rayman, Scheurle said in the GDC talk, designers include a bit of "coyote time": some wiggle room at the edge of a platform, named for Wile E. Coyote running off a cliff and hanging in the air for a second before he drops. It may seem unfair once you know about it. Scheurle's point was that it cuts down on frustration and keeps players in a flow state, so they keep running and jumping rather than restarting.

Other games forgive in quieter ways. GamesRadar's roundup of the tricks Scheurle crowdsourced notes that Bloodborne temporarily turns off your character's collisions while you reload, so a stray hit doesn't restart the animation. In Firewatch, Campo Santo's Jane Ng explained, saying nothing at a dialogue prompt is itself counted as a response. Even hesitation, it turns out, is a choice.

Leaving you just alive

The thread's loudest lesson, in PC Gamer's summary, was "Never trust health bars." Scheurle said that in Assassin's Creed Origins and Doom the last section of the health bar holds more hit points than it appears to, so that, as GamesRadar put it, when you see 15% left you actually have 30%. Another reply in the thread said that in BioShock, taking what should have been your final point of damage instead made you invulnerable for a second or two, for more "barely survived" moments. The original Assassin's Creed did a related thing, according to game director Ashraf Ismail as quoted in Scheurle's talk: the final block of health regenerates faster than the rest, so players feel they're escaping by the skin of their teeth.

Ammunition gets the same treatment. One developer told the thread that in System Shock the last bullet did double damage. Gears of War, GamesRadar reports, makes the last shot in the magazine the most powerful, and its Lee Perry described giving new multiplayer players damage bonuses that tapered off after their first few kills, after the team "found out 90% of first-time players don't play a second multiplayer match if they don't get a kill".

Some games lean on tension rather than survival. Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes' Ben Kane explained that distractions like the alarm clock depend on how well you're doing, which makes last-second defusals more likely.

Enemies with good manners

"As many of you know, building super-powerful AI is pretty easy," Scheurle told the GDC audience. "Building AI that 'feels good' is pretty difficult." The examples bear her out. BioShock's Splicers always miss with their first shot, giving you time to spot them and react, and Assassin's Creed has its own "safety belt" version of the same rule. In Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice, she said, enemies behind the player are on a timer that stops them attacking from behind too quickly.

GamesRadar's list goes further. Far Cry 4 turns down the accuracy and damage of enemies standing closer to you. Batman: Arkham Asylum's thugs avoid turning a full 180 degrees, so you can sneak up behind them. Devil May Cry slows or stops attacks from enemies off screen. In Silent Hill: Shattered Memories, Sam Barlow revealed, the creatures in its chases lose a sense each time you respawn and slow down when you look over your shoulder, and only two are ever allowed to chase you directly.

Why it stays hidden, and when it shouldn't

The tricks work because you don't see them. A health bar that admitted it was lying wouldn't produce the feeling it exists to produce. The same is true of the spectacle: one developer in the thread admitted adding health back to duelling uruks in Shadow of Mordor to stretch their fights out a little longer.

That's also where it gets touchy. Scheurle noted that the reaction to her thread was mixed: players in particular were a bit shocked to see how their favourite games work. She pointed to rubber-banding in games like Mario Kart, which can frustrate players who feel their rivals are getting an unfair boost, even if it keeps races close. Asked at GDC whether designers should be sharing these secrets at all, she said designers always need to be ready to explain their work: "I think it's very valuable, even if it causes conflict."

None of this should be confused with the other kind of hidden thing in games, the production workaround. Kotaku's collection of developer confessions includes horses in the first Assassin's Creed built from twisted human skeleton rigs, because the team's tech only worked properly with bipeds. That's a trick on the developers' behalf. The mechanics above are tricks on yours, and the fair takeaway is that the game is usually rooting for you, quietly, and would rather you didn't check the maths.

Sources

More from Xarmo News